After making a bold and widely criticized comment following the 2023 NFL Draft, NFL writer Greg Rosenthal has finally owned up to his misjudgment regarding Detroit Lions running backs Jahmyr Gibbs and David Montgomery.
In the aftermath of the Lions selecting Gibbs, Rosenthal tweeted, “The difference between David Montgomery/Jahmyr Gibbs and Jamaal Williams/D’Andre Swift is not large,” a statement that many Lions fans, and even Rosenthal himself, now acknowledge as a significant understatement.
The Duo’s Explosive 2024 Performance
By 2024, Gibbs and Montgomery have not only surpassed expectations but have also become one of the most formidable running back duos in the NFL. Observers are even considering them as one of the best tandems in league history, with both players making key contributions to the Lions’ high-powered offense.
Rosenthal’s Apology in New Orleans
While in New Orleans before Super Bowl LIX, Rosenthal took the opportunity to apologize directly to both players. “I formally apologized for this tweet, and Gibbs told me I need to ‘eat that for a lot longer,’” Rosenthal revealed. “I mean … Gibbs is a top-3 RB in the league, and they are one of the best duos of my entire life.”
A Duo That Shattered Expectations
Rosenthal’s apology comes after a season where Gibbs firmly established himself among the NFL’s elite, while Montgomery proved to be a key piece of Detroit’s offense. Their performances have shown that Rosenthal’s initial comparison was far from accurate.
Once undervalued by some including Rosenthal both Gibbs and Montgomery have proven their worth. As the Lions’ backfield continues to impress, it’s clear that this dynamic duo is one of the most feared in the league, leaving an unforgettable mark on NFL fans.
