Five Yankees Likely to Leave During the MLB Winter Meetings
The New York Yankees, following their disappointing World Series loss to the Los Angeles Dodgers in five games, are poised for significant roster changes this offseason. As they head into the MLB Winter Meetings, key decisions loom, especially with uncertainty surrounding Juan Soto’s free agency. Here’s a look at five Yankees likely to depart this offseason and the reasons behind their potential exits.
1. Clay Holmes: Too Inconsistent for the Yankees’ Needs
Clay Holmes has been one of the Yankees’ top relievers statistically, posting a 2.69 ERA in 220 appearances. However, his inconsistency has proven costly, with fluctuating performances throughout the 2024 season. While he started the year strong and ended on a high note, Holmes endured several rough patches, including a 5.68 ERA over a 20-game stretch.
Given the demand for reliable back-end bullpen options, Holmes will likely command a hefty salary in free agency. The Yankees, aiming for stability in high-leverage situations, seem unlikely to bring him back.
2. Anthony Rizzo: Declining Performance Ends His Bronx Tenure
Anthony Rizzo’s decline over the past two seasons has made his return to the Yankees unlikely. After a stellar first full season in New York, Rizzo struggled mightily in 2024, batting just .228 with eight home runs and a career-low OPS+ of 81.
New York opted to pay him a $6 million buyout rather than exercise his $17 million club option, signaling their intention to upgrade at first base. With power hitters like Christian Walker and Pete Alonso available in free agency, the Yankees are prioritizing offensive production over loyalty.
3. Gleyber Torres: A Long-Awaited Departure
After years of trade rumors, Gleyber Torres appears poised to leave the Yankees. While he remains a capable power hitter, slashing .257/.330/.378 with 15 home runs in 2024, his defensive limitations and inconsistent production have made him expendable.
The Yankees’ roster flexibility, including the presence of Jazz Chisholm Jr., makes it easier to move on from Torres. With pressing needs in other areas, Torres is likely to find a new team before the Winter Meetings conclude.
4. Alex Verdugo: Outfield Spot to Be Filled by Jasson Dominguez
Alex Verdugo’s time in the Bronx appears to be over, particularly with Jasson Dominguez emerging as an MLB-ready outfield option. Verdugo’s performance plummeted after a promising first month, finishing the season with a .225/.275/.336 slash line and a 72 WRC+ from May onward.
Dominguez, coupled with Aaron Judge and possibly Juan Soto, represents the Yankees’ future outfield core, leaving no room for Verdugo.
5. Marcus Stroman: Trade Candidate After Underwhelming Season
Though under contract for 2025, Marcus Stroman may not stay with the Yankees long. After signing with high expectations, Stroman delivered a lackluster 4.31 ERA across 29 starts. His advanced metrics, including a career-low strikeout rate (16.7%), underscore his struggles.
Stroman’s postseason exclusion by manager Aaron Boone highlights the team’s lack of confidence in him. With the Yankees’ rotation already set, trading Stroman to clear payroll and create flexibility appears inevitable. Despite his down year, his track record should attract suitors in need of pitching depth.
