After a disappointing exit from the Wild Card series, the Houston Astros are facing major roster challenges this offseason. With the likely departures of key players like Alex Bregman and veteran pitcher Justin Verlander, the Astros will need to take proactive steps to fill these gaps to stay competitive.
One critical position they need to address is first base. Here are three potential trades that could not only fill key roster spots but also bring fresh talent to the Astros lineup.
Given their struggling farm system, which ranks as the worst in baseball, the Astros will likely need to look for talent outside the organization. Trades within the division are highly unlikely, so players from the A’s, Rangers, Angels, and Mariners aren’t considered here. However, there are still some promising trade options available.
Targeting Yandy Díaz from the Rays
With Alex Bregman expected to leave, the Astros need a solid replacement at third base, and Yandy Díaz from the Tampa Bay Rays could be a great fit. Díaz had a strong 2024 season, with a .281 batting average and a .341 on-base percentage, showcasing his excellent plate discipline and power. In 2023, he enjoyed a breakout year, hitting .330/.410/.522, earning All-Star recognition, a Silver Slugger award, and finishing sixth in MVP voting.
The Astros could trade for Díaz by offering Rhett Kouba, a right-handed pitcher close to making his MLB debut, and Chase Jaworsky, a versatile infielder from Single-A with solid potential. This deal would provide the Rays with future talent for their system while giving the Astros a reliable third baseman to replace Bregman.
Christian Encarnacion-Strand
With José Abreu’s departure creating a gap at first base, Christian Encarnacion-Strand from the Cincinnati Reds could be a promising target. Despite a rough 2024 season with a .190/.220/.293 slash line, Encarnacion-Strand has significant upside. In his minor league career from 2022-2023, he hit .322/.386/.604 with 56 home runs in just 211 games, demonstrating impressive power.
The Astros could offer a trade package including Zach Cole, a talented outfielder in Double-A, Nick Hernandez, a reliable bullpen arm, and Forrest Whitley, a former top prospect looking for a fresh start. This deal would give the Reds a mix of immediate and future value while the Astros gain a power-hitting first baseman.
Freddy Peralta
With Justin Verlander’s potential departure impacting the rotation, Freddy Peralta from the Milwaukee Brewers could be an ideal addition. Although he faced challenges in 2024, Peralta still struck out 200 batters in 173.2 innings with a 3.68 ERA. His ability to handle a heavy workload and deliver strikeouts would greatly benefit the Astros.
To acquire Peralta, the Astros could offer Pedro Leon, an outfield prospect with power and speed, along with Trey Dombroski, a promising left-handed pitcher from Double-A. Adding some cash to the deal might make it more appealing for the Brewers, while the Astros would strengthen their pitching staff with a proven performer.
Conclusion
These trade proposals aim not just to fill immediate needs but to strengthen the Astros’ roster strategically. Yandy Díaz could provide stability at third base both offensively and defensively. Freddy Peralta would add a reliable arm to the rotation, and Christian Encarnacion-Strand could deliver the much-needed power at first base.
By making these moves, the Astros would signal their commitment to remaining contenders in the American League. Each targeted player brings a mix of youth and experience that complements the current roster, setting up the team for a strong comeback in the 2025 season and beyond.
