Debating the Oilers’ Goalie Situation: Is Skinner’s Early-Game Struggles a Concern?
Analyst Louie DeBrusk recently weighed in on trade rumors suggesting the Edmonton Oilers could add another goaltender before the deadline. While arguing against a midseason move—believing it could send the wrong message to Stuart Skinner—DeBrusk may have inadvertently highlighted a key weakness in Skinner’s game.
DeBrusk pointed out Skinner’s tendency to allow early goals, emphasizing that the Oilers have the resilience to recover from deficits. However, in doing so, he may have unintentionally drawn attention to the fact that Skinner often puts the team in a tough position. “He really settles in after letting in 2 or 3 early,” DeBrusk noted.
For some fans, what was meant to be a defense of Skinner instead confirmed concerns about his reliability early in games. While not directly suggesting Skinner is untrustworthy, the numbers tell their own story—over the last 10 games, he has allowed three first-period goals five times. Additionally, nearly half of the goals conceded by the Oilers in recent weeks have come in quick succession, a troubling trend for a team with playoff aspirations.
Should the Oilers Consider a Backup Plan?
DeBrusk warned that bringing in another goaltender midseason could disrupt team chemistry and undermine Skinner’s confidence. He also argued that Skinner deserves the opportunity to prove he can handle the pressure. However, history suggests that a timely goalie acquisition can make a major impact—just as it did in 2006 when the Oilers brought in Dwayne Roloson for their Cinderella run to the Stanley Cup Final.
While the Oilers aren’t in the same position of uncertainty in net as they were then, having a reliable backup option could be crucial if Skinner’s struggles persist. If his issues continue leading up to the March 7 trade deadline, Edmonton may have no choice but to explore alternatives.
