The perception of the Miami Marlins’ recent trades has sparked debate, but a closer look reveals there might be less controversy than initially assumed.
Jake Burger Trade: A Pragmatic Decision
Miami Marlins fans expressed shock when Jake Burger was traded to the Texas Rangers, a move some deemed pointless. However, a deeper analysis shows the trade was more calculated than it seemed.
Burger, while a power hitter with 34 home runs in 2024 (29 with the Marlins), struggled in other areas. His defensive metrics were poor, with a -1.1 dWAR for the season, prompting his move from third base to first base. Offensively, he struggled with strikeouts, below-average batting averages, and on-base percentages, resulting in a meager 0.5 WAR for 2024.
At nearly 29 years old, Burger’s limited skill set—highlighted by his lack of speed, defensive ability, and on-base consistency—diminished his value. With better options like Jonah Bride and Agustin Ramirez for the 1B/DH role, the Marlins made a strategic decision to part ways. The trade wasn’t about finances but about recognizing Burger’s limited role in the team’s future.
The Luzardo Trade: A Risky Bet on Prospects
The Marlins also made headlines by trading starting pitcher Jesús Luzardo to the Philadelphia Phillies for prospects SS Starlyn Caba, catcher Paul McIntosh, and OF Emaarion Boyd.
Luzardo, despite strong performances in 2022 and 2023 (3.48 ERA/3.40 FIP), faced setbacks in 2024 due to injuries, with a disappointing 5.00 ERA/4.26 FIP over 12 games. With free agency looming and health concerns mounting, the Marlins opted to trade him.
The return package, however, has raised eyebrows. The centerpiece, Starlyn Caba, is an elite defensive shortstop with great plate discipline but limited power, currently in Single-A at age 19. Emaarion Boyd, another Single-A prospect, offers elite speed and defense but lacks hitting prowess. Paul McIntosh, a solid defensive catcher, is already 26 years old, limiting his long-term potential.
While the return seems underwhelming, it may reflect concerns over Luzardo’s health. This gamble could pay off if the prospects develop as hoped, but the Phillies’ immediate upgrade strengthens their chances in a competitive NL East.
Final Verdict
Both trades reflect a clear-eyed reassessment of player value and team strategy. The Marlins prioritized long-term flexibility over short-term gains, even if the moves initially seemed controversial.
