The New York Yankees made waves by trading veteran catcher Jose Trevino to the Cincinnati Reds in exchange for right-handed pitcher Fernando Cruz and catcher Alex Jackson, as first reported by Jon Heyman and Joel Sherman of the New York Post. While the Yankees had a surplus of catching talent after adding Jesus Rodriguez and JC Escarra to the 40-man roster, it was uncertain whether they’d part with key players like Trevino or Austin Wells. With Trevino entering the final year of his contract, General Manager Brian Cashman seized the opportunity to strengthen the bullpen and acquire depth at catcher.
Yankees Add Elite Strikeout Reliever to the Bullpen
Fernando Cruz emerges as the centerpiece of this trade, bringing high strikeout potential to a Yankees bullpen that ranked just 12th in strikeout rate last season. Cruz, one of MLB’s top swing-and-miss relievers, boasts an impressive 34.8% strikeout rate since 2022, ranking sixth among qualified relievers. Despite his 4.67 ERA raising some eyebrows, his arsenal—particularly a devastating splitter—offers immense upside.
Cruz’s splitter is a standout weapon, generating a jaw-dropping 59% whiff rate in 2023 while holding opponents to a minuscule .116 batting average. Statcast metrics back its dominance, as it earned the highest Stuff+ rating (162) among splitters thrown last season. However, Cruz’s fastball remains a liability, with opposing hitters capitalizing on both his four-seam fastball and cutter. If the Yankees’ coaching staff can refine these offerings, Cruz has the potential to become one of the American League’s most dominant relievers.
Adding to his appeal is Cruz’s affordability and club control, with four years remaining under contract. He fits seamlessly into the Yankees’ short- and long-term plans, offering an immediate upgrade while keeping payroll flexibility intact.
Trevino Brings Leadership and Defense to Cincinnati
For the Reds, acquiring Jose Trevino fills a glaring need at catcher. Known more for his defensive prowess than his bat, Trevino’s two-year stint with the Yankees was marked by exceptional play behind the plate. He claimed a Platinum Glove in 2022 and ranks second in Fielding Run Value among catchers since joining the Yankees (+36).
Trevino’s veteran presence will be invaluable for Cincinnati’s young pitching staff, and his modest salary makes him a cost-effective addition. With just one year of club control remaining, the Reds could explore a contract extension to secure his services beyond 2024.
What’s Next for the Yankees’ Catching Depth?
Though Alex Jackson joined the Yankees in this trade, his limited offensive upside raises questions about his role on the 2025 roster. Meanwhile, JC Escarra, who impressed in 2024, could step in to help fill the void left by Trevino. The Yankees appear confident in their catching depth, leveraging it to address a critical bullpen need in a move that reshapes their roster for the upcoming season.
This trade highlights the Yankees’ aggressive offseason approach, aiming to solidify weaknesses while keeping an eye on the future. For both teams, the deal represents a calculated gamble with the potential for significant upside.
