MLB Contract Update: Shane Bieber Stays with Guardians, Braves Miss Out
Shane Bieber, a prominent free-agent starting pitcher, has opted to re-sign with the Cleveland Guardians, putting to rest speculation linking him to teams like the Atlanta Braves, St. Louis Cardinals, and Texas Rangers. The Guardians prioritized retaining Bieber and succeeded with a deal announced on Friday.
According to Jeff Passan, Bieber’s new contract is a one-year agreement worth $14 million, with a $16 million player option for 2026. Despite interest from other teams offering higher salaries, Bieber chose to stay in Cleveland, as reported by Jon Heyman.
Contract Analysis: A Calculated Gamble by Cleveland
Bieber’s return is significant, though its immediate impact on the Guardians’ 2025 season might be limited. After undergoing Tommy John surgery, the two-time All-Star and Cy Young Award winner is not expected to return to full strength until mid-season. His presence will be critical for Cleveland’s postseason aspirations under new manager Stephen Vogt.
In 2024, Bieber pitched in only two games before being sidelined, delivering 12 scoreless innings with 20 strikeouts. If he can replicate that dominance in the latter half of 2025, the $14 million investment could prove to be a bargain.
While there is risk in signing a player coming off major surgery, Bieber’s track record—including a Triple Crown and an All-Star pedigree—makes this a worthwhile gamble. The player option for 2026 further adds flexibility, potentially benefiting Cleveland in the long term.
At 30 years old when the 2025 season begins, Bieber still has time to solidify his legacy in MLB and make a significant impact in Cleveland.
Final Contract Grade: A
