Alex Anthopoulos has a talent for making timely decisions for the Braves. However, 2024 proved to be a tough year for Atlanta, and they were relatively inactive during the trade deadline. They traded Jorge Soler and Luke Jackson back to their previous team in San Francisco, hoping to recapture the success they had in 2021.
Soler’s return to Atlanta began positively; he had a batting average of .297 in his first ten games, collecting 11 hits, including a double, four home runs, ten RBIs, six walks, and 12 strikeouts. Unfortunately, his performance declined, ending August with a .203 average. Although he walked 15 times during that period—a good sign—he also struck out 22 times.
The final month of the season showed improvement as Soler’s average climbed to .288, with 23 hits, including nine doubles, four home runs, and 12 RBIs, resulting in a .913 OPS. Despite this turnaround, he couldn’t help the Braves navigate a disappointing season.
However, while the offense thrived, Soler became a defensive liability for Atlanta, recording a -7 Outs Above Average (OAA) and -10 Defensive Runs Saved (DRS) in 2024. Having played primarily as a designated hitter for the Giants, Soler found himself in the outfield for Atlanta, as Marcell Ozuna already occupied the DH spot. This move proved problematic as Soler struggled defensively, negatively impacting the team during crucial moments, leaving the Braves at a pivotal point for the upcoming season.
Soler is under contract for two more years at $16 million annually, raising questions about whether the team can afford to keep him, especially given his defensive shortcomings. With Ozuna likely returning as the designated hitter in 2025, Anthopoulos may need to seek a trade partner willing to take on Soler’s remaining $32 million contract, which could mean Atlanta has to absorb some salary.
On the other hand, Ramon Laureano made a strong impression on Braves fans after his call-up in 2024, showcasing excellent defensive skills that would be a better fit for the outfield. The front office should not overlook the possibility of using more suitable players instead of relying on Soler’s inconsistent defense.
While a platoon arrangement with Jarred Kelenic in left field could be an option, paying $16 million for a platoon player is not ideal. Trading Soler seems the most logical move, as he primarily serves as a DH, a position already filled.
Anthopoulos faces a significant challenge with the acquisition of Soler. The trade could make sense if the team decides not to retain Marcell Ozuna, but that would be surprising given the current plans. As a result, Soler appears to be expendable, and it will be interesting to see how Atlanta’s front office proceeds.
